Who else remembers/Misses CoverGirl Full Lash Bloom mascara and knows a good replacement that separates and holds a curl?

I have medium-ish length, sparse, blondish, stick straight lashes that are all over the place.
Before I discovered Katy Perry's fav. (Bloom) like 10-ish years ago, nothing separated and held my curling wand curl. Bloom also seemed to never flake or smudge, but rinsed right off in the shower with no effort or even makeup remover!
Bloom seems to be gone and I've tried several things since, but they either drop my curl, clump, don't give me any length, or just are meh.

If anyone loved this one/knows its formula and knows a good dupe, plz tell me!

I don't use waterproof mascara - too hard to clean at the end of the day and I lose lashes each time.

Also, I've recently tried Honest (didn't like it bc it flakes and doesn't hold curl), Tower 28 (I hated more than any other - shape of wand doesn't give me length, flakes instantly, doesn't hold curl), and L'Oreal Extentionist which is okay but a bit thick and clumpy and doesn't separate.